Leer en: Español

Stem Cells in Focus

Stem Cell Soup – The Importance of Knowing What Is In It

“I don’t even know what’s in the soup,” was the shocking quote from the founder of a chain of clinics highlighted in a recent Associated Press article about the increasing prevalence of clinics offering unproven stem cell therapies. The “soup” referred to the mixture of cells and fluid he extracted from a patient’s fat for re-injection into the same patient’s knees, one of many “stem cell” procedures being tried for more than 20 diseases and conditions.

Clinics that offer such “soup” and other so-called “stem cell treatments” that have not been rigorously tested have been the focus of considerable attention lately. In recent months, two highly-publicized scientific reports document the rapid, world-wide, growth of such clinics. In the U.S., the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) released draft guidance documents to clarify regulatory expectations, including that cells harvested from fat and introduced into a different part of the body are subject to FDA oversight, and held a public hearing in September to hear comments on the proposed guidance.

The FDA hearing was a chance for the ISSCR and others to reiterate the importance of regulating stem cell treatments, including those using one’s own cells. The reasons why unproven treatments are still available for sale is nuanced. However, the widespread scientific concerns that these unproven treatments continue to proliferate in the absence of rigorous scientific support are not.

A fundamental concern is the lack of characterization of these treatments. This begins with the use of the term “stem cells.” Cells should only be defined as stem cells if rigorous criteria are met: a demonstrated capacity to self-renew (to give rise to more stem cells) and to give rise to specialized cell types such as blood cells or muscle cells.

This issue is particularly concerning as it relates to the use of the term “mesenchymal stem cells” (MSCs) to describe the desired cells extracted from a patient’s fat. Not only is there considerable skepticism in the field about whether these MSCs manifest so-called “stemness” but there is no way to know how many MSCs are even in the “soup” extracted from fat.

The identification of MSCs requires the cells to be grown in a laboratory for days under special conditions or the use of specific MSC markers to identify and isolate them, although the reliability of these markers is still being debated. What this means for the patient is that the same-day treatments with the “soup” are likely to be a mixture of fat and other specialized cell types with no reliable information on whether MSCs are present and if so, how many are present.

Additionally, stem cells from different tissues have different functions and there is still debate about whether MSCs from all tissue sources (fat versus bone marrow, for example) have the same properties. Furthermore, research on other adult stem cells has shown that stem cells can decline in frequency and function as they age. How these and other biological factors might influence the effects of MSCs is unknown.

The lack of rigorous evaluation of the “soup” and similar “treatments” raises many questions that can only be addressed by rigorous scientific study and clinical trials. Authentic patient testimonials can highlight individual results, but they fail to capture all patients’ experiences, and thus fail to give a complete assessment of the therapy. This commercial marketing strategy is reminiscent of the infomercials where an enthusiastic user excitedly promotes the product’s benefits while the small print at the bottom of the screen reads, “results may not be typical.”

The increase of purported stem cell treatments with little to no evidence of clinical utility, and in some cases a disregard of the known cell- or tissue- biology, has led many scientific organizations to take action.  The ISSCR has released updated professional guidelines for its members and the stem cell community that contain explicit condemnation of “…unproven stem cell-based interventions outside of the context of clinical research…”  Other organizations, such as the American Thoracic Society, the Australasian College of Sports Physicians, among other groups, have released cautionary statements that speak to specific unproven treatments within their specialty areas.

The ISSCR has also developed an informational website, a CloserLookatStemCells.org, designed to help people understand the basics of stem cell science and more. It provides facts about the research and probative questions to consider when evaluating potential clinical trials or stem cell interventions.

Stem cells offer the potential to treat many intractable disease and injuries but there is still a lot to learn about their therapeutic potential. The clear path forward for this relies upon rigorous testing of the safety and effectiveness of the potential treatment in clinical trials and the sharing of experimental and clinical data to ensure that clinical applications are evidence-based.

22 comments

Leave a comment
  1. dedi galih wisnumurti | Nov 22, 2017
    Keep up the excellent work , I read few articles on this site and I think that your web blog is real interesting and Power to the People of excellent information.1. Jasa SEO2. Google SEO3. Pembuatan Website4. Google Adwords5. SEO6. WebsiteJasa SEOGoogle AdwordsPembuatan Website7. Sewa Villa di Puncak8. Villa di Puncak
  2. RObinjack | Nov 22, 2017
    Much thanks for keep this data.  Mroyun
  3. ADOLF | Nov 22, 2017
    I admire your work , regards for all the useful blog posts newintrends.com savingdeals.com
  4. Robinjack | Nov 22, 2017
    Much obliged for sharing us about this redesign. Trust you won't get tired on making posts as enlightening as this.  escorts in lebanon
  5. Taniya sharma | Nov 22, 2017
    Awesome Information sharing .. I am extremely cheerful to peruse this article .. much obliged for giving us experience info.Fantastic decent.  Hifi Escorts Service in Delhi
  6. RObinjack | Nov 21, 2017
    Amazing data on your site, thank you for setting aside an ideal opportunity to impart to us. Stunning understanding you have on this present, it's pleasant to discover a site that subtle elements such a great amount of data about distinctive specialists.  online casino bonus
  7. RObinjack | Nov 21, 2017
    I high value this post. It's elusive the great from the terrible now and then, however I think you've nailed it! would you brain overhauling your web journal with more data?  autoradio gps 2017 click web site
  8. RObinjack | Nov 19, 2017
    There is such a great amount in this article I would never have considered all alone. Your substance gives perusers things to consider in an intriguing way. Much obliged to you for your unmistakable data.  beirut escorts
  9. dedi galih wisnumurti | Nov 16, 2017
    Nice post. I learn something more challenging on distinct blogs everyday. It will always be stimulating to read content off their writers and practice a little something from their store. I’d choose to use some with all the content in my small weblog whether you do not mind. Natually I’ll provide a link on your own internet weblog. Many thanks sharing.1. Jasa SEO2. Jasa SEO3. Google SEO4. Jasa Pembuatan WebsiteDAN INI TUKANG NYEPAM KAMI1. Sewa Villa Di Puncak2. Villa Puncak
  10. alukar | Nov 06, 2017
    Take every chance you get in life, because some things only happen once cara menyembuhkan buang air kecil terasa nyeri, perih dan terbakar
  11. alukar | Nov 06, 2017
    Take every chance you get in life, because some things only happen once cara menyembuhkan buang air kecil terasa nyeri, perih dan terbakar
  12. david | Nov 05, 2017
    This is the kind of data I"ve long been attempting to discover. Much thanks to you for composing this data. at their website
  13. Jeni Rabb | Oct 26, 2017
    Tahan aus Tahan aus merupakan. Paduan logam yang digunakan untuk meningkatkan kemampuan tahan aus diantaranya nikel, chrom, dan vanadium. Efek utama elemen paduan utama untuk baja [8]  Toko Plat Bordes Toko Plat Bordes Pabrik bondek Toko Wiremesh Besi Pabrik besi unp undangan pernikahan cantik Distributor Besi Hollow undangan pernikahan simple Jual Besi Hollow Baja Toko besi hollow Distributor besi beton Sni Ulir Polos Agen Plat Bordes Agen Plat Bordes jual hp asus murah jual hp asus murah Pabrik Plat kapal besi baja bki krakatau steel Agen Wiremesh Besi Pabrik besi siku undangan pernikahan simple Distributor Wiremesh Harga Besi Hollow Baja jual laptop asus jual laptop asus jual laptop asus murah jual laptop asus murah Agen besi hollow Distributor besi beton ais Pabrik Plat Bordes Pabrik Plat Bordes Pabrik besi siku Pabrik Wiremesh Besi Pabrik Plat besi plat kapal undangan pernikahan mewah Distributor Besi Pipa Baja Schedule 80 Pabrik Besi Hollow Baja Pabrik besi hollow Distributor besi beton Distributor Wiremesh Besi Distributor Wiremesh Besi Pabrik pipa besi baja sch 40 sch 80 Distributor Atap Spandek Pabrik besi h beam baja undangan pernikahan cute Distributor Besi Pipa Baja Schedule 40 Distributor Besi Beton Distributor pipa besi jasa konstruksi baja Harga Wiremesh Besi Harga Wiremesh Besi Pabrik Plat besi Harga Atap Spandek Pabrik besi cnp undangan pernikahan modern undangan pernikahan online undangan pernikahan biru Distributor Pipa Besi Hitam Medium Supplier Besi Beton Harga pipa besi www.pusatbesibaja.co.id Jual Wiremesh Besi Jual Wiremesh Besi Pabrik besi h beam Jual Atap Spandek www.gudangbesibaja.com undangan pernikahan buatan sendiri Distributor Besi Wf Agen Besi Beton Jual pipa besi www.pusatbesibaja.com Supplier Wiremesh Besi Supplier Wiremesh Besi Pabrik besi wf Supplier Atap Spandek Distributor besi Wf Baja undangan pernikahan bahasa inggris islam Distributor Besi H beam Toko Besi Beton Supplier pipa besi www.jualbesibajamurah.com Toko Wiremesh Besi Toko Wiremesh Besi Pabrik wiremesh Toko Atap Spandek Distributor bondek undangan pernikahan amplop surat Distributor Besi Beton Jual Besi Beton Toko pipa besi Jual besi beton Sni Ulir Polos polos ulir Agen Wiremesh Besi Agen Wiremesh Besi Pabrik besi unp Agen Atap Spandek undangan pernikahan undangan pernikahan amplop surat Distributor wiremesh undangan pernikahan unik dan murah www.sentrabesibaja.com Harga Besi Beton Agen pipa besi Jual besi beton sii Pabrik Wiremesh Besi Pabrik Wiremesh Besi Pabrik besi cnp Pabrik Atap Spandek Distributor pipa besi baja sch 40 sch 80 undangan pernikahan elegan Jual Welded Beam T beam King Queen Cross Castellated Beam Pabrik Besi Beton Pabrik pipa besi Jual besi beton psi Ulir Polos Distributor Atap Spandek Distributor Atap Spandek Pabrik besi hollow Distributor Bondek Cor Distributor besi hollow undangan pernikahan animasi Jual Bondek Cor Distributor Besi Wf Baja Distributor sch 40 Jual besi beton perwira Harga Atap Spandek Harga Atap Spandek Pabrik besi beton Sni Ulir Polos Harga Bondek Cor Distributor besi beton Sni Ulir Polos undangan pernikahan lucu Jual Atap Spandek Sni Supplier Besi Wf Baja Harga sch 40 Jual besi beton PAS Jual Atap Spandek Jual Atap Spandek ironsteelcenter.com Jual Bondek Cor Distributor besi wf baja undangan pernikahan kalender Jual Plat Bordes Kembang Agen Besi Wf Baja Jual sch 40 Jual besi beton master steel ms Supplier Atap Spandek Supplier Atap Spandek Distributor stainless steel Supplier Bondek Cor Distributor besi unp undangan pernikahan ala india Jual Plat Besi Hitam Toko Besi Wf Baja Supplier sch 40 Jual besi beton ksty Toko Atap Spandek Toko Atap Spandek Distributor atap spandek Toko Bondek Cor Distributor besi siku undangan pernikahan klasik Jual Plat Kapal Bki Krakatau Steel Jual Besi Wf Baja Toko sch 40 Jual besi beton krakatau steel ks link5 
  14. sugiana | Oct 25, 2017
    I was reading the provided article with a great interest! This post is useful and informative. cara cepat untuk mengeringkan luka operasi caesar yang bernanah
  15. sugiana | Oct 25, 2017
    I was reading the provided article with a great interest! This post is useful and informative. cara cepat untuk mengeringkan luka operasi caesar yang bernanah
  16. sumanth12 | Oct 24, 2017
    Nice post, thanks for sharing this. We provide Lenovo Customer service.If you have any issues related to Lenovo Laptop then visit here:Lenovo Support Number
  17. mikasa | Oct 24, 2017
    I was reading the provided article with a great interest! This post is useful and informative. cara mengatasi nyeri tumit, pengobatan alternatif sembuhkan penyakit splenomegali, obat fibroadenoma mammae
  18. mikasa | Oct 24, 2017
    I was reading the provided article with a great interest! This post is useful and informative. cara mengatasi nyeri tumit, pengobatan alternatif sembuhkan penyakit splenomegali, obat fibroadenoma mammae
  19. Lance Mosley | Oct 20, 2017
    It is a dynamic blog site to seek out and contains depth information with full coverage. Thanks much.  Video to JPG Converter mac
  20. mellisa | Oct 18, 2017
    Hmm… I didn't know there were that many ingredients in the soup. Would love to know whats in the 3D Virtual Reality Headset as well now.
  21. frank | Oct 18, 2017
    Hmm… I didn't know there were that many ingredients in the soup. Would love to know whats in the <a href="https://m.eagleeyevr.com/3d-virtual-reality-headset/">3D Virtual Reality Headset</a> as well now.
  22. Padma | Oct 08, 2017
    Thank you, Scott, for sharing it's importance here. I hope you'll make use of your best dissertation help skills more in the future and be even better.

    Leave a comment